Hiring a Property Manager vs. Self-Managing: What’s Better?

Are you a landlord debating whether to handle property management on your own or bring in a professional?

This decision often involves weighing the challenges of self-management against the benefits of enlisting expert help.

While self-management might seem appealing due to the allure of greater control and potential cost savings, the advantages of partnering with a professional property manager frequently outweigh these perceived benefits. 

To assist you in navigating this decision, Home Choice Property Management has created this comprehensive guide, offering insights and considerations to help you make the best choice for your property.

Keep reading to learn more!

Understanding the Roles

Firstly, it’s essential to understand what property management entails. 

A property manager’s responsibilities can include marketing rentals, collecting rent, handling maintenance and repair issues, responding to tenant complaints, and even pursuing evictions. 

Imagine having to juggle all these tasks personally as a landlord, often alongside other professional and personal responsibilities. 

Oftentimes, self-managing your rental properties can create a lot of stress and time constraints due to the complexities of property management responsibilities.

The Benefits of Hiring a Property Manager

Expertise and Experience

Property managers bring a level of expertise that is hard to match through self-management unless one has a background in real estate. 

They understand the legal and regulatory frameworks surrounding property rentals, which vary by location and can be complex and ever-changing. 

This expertise helps in efficiently navigating situations like tenant screening, lease negotiations, and eviction procedures, reducing the risks of costly legal mistakes.

Effective Marketing and Tenant Screening

Filling vacancies can be one of the most challenging aspects of managing a rental property. 

a-couple-and-their-property-manager-sitting-on-a-couch

Property managers have the skills and resources to market your property effectively. 

They often have established platforms and professional networks to advertise your rental to a broader audience, ensuring quicker tenant placement. 

Moreover, they have systems in place for thorough tenant screening, which helps in securing reliable tenants who are likely to pay rent on time, treat the property with respect, and cause fewer problems.

Day-to-Day Management and Emergency Handling

Day-to-day property management can be incredibly time-consuming. 

From regular maintenance checks to emergency responses at odd hours, self-managing landlords can quickly find themselves overwhelmed. 

Property managers have processes and staff in place to handle these tasks efficiently, including a network of trusted contractors to handle repairs promptly. 

This not only ensures the property is well-maintained but also aids in tenant satisfaction and retention.

Distance Management

For landlords who don’t live near their rental properties or those with multiple properties, managing logistics can become unfeasible

A property manager acts as a local point of contact for tenants and addresses issues directly.

This is particularly beneficial for landlords who view their rental properties as an investment rather than a full-time job.

Improved Tenant Retention

Tenant turnover can be costly and stressful. Property managers understand the importance of tenant retention and are skilled in tenant relations. 

By promptly addressing concerns and maintaining the property, they help create a satisfactory experience for tenants, which often translates to longer lease terms and lower turnover rates.

Scalability

If you plan to expand your rental property portfolio, self-managing can quickly become unsustainable. 

Property managers are equipped to handle multiple properties, allowing you to grow your investment portfolio without a proportional increase in your workload.

Risks of Self-managing a Rental Property

Self-managing a rental property can come with a variety of risks that can affect everything from the profitability of your investments to your personal stress levels. 

Here are some of the primary risks associated with self-management:

Legal and Regulatory Non-Compliance

One of the most significant risks involves legal issues. 

Landlords must navigate a complex array of local, state, and federal regulations, including fair housing laws, rental and building codes, and tenant rights laws. 

Failure to comply with these regulations can lead to hefty fines, legal disputes, and even lawsuits. 

For those without a background in real estate law, keeping up with the constant changes in legislation can be particularly challenging.

Inefficient Tenant Screening

Effective tenant screening is crucial for maintaining a reliable stream of income from rental properties. 

Self-managing landlords might not have access to the same resources or experience as property managers in conducting thorough background checks, which can increase the risk of renting to tenants who might default on payments, damage property, or cause legal troubles.

Higher Vacancy Rates

Marketing a property effectively requires both skill and resources. 

Without the expertise in how to market properties effectively across multiple channels or the time to show the property, self-managing landlords might experience longer vacancy periods.

Extended vacancies can significantly impact the profitability of rental properties.

Maintenance Issues

Proper maintenance of a property is vital to preserve its value and ensure tenant satisfaction.

Self-managers may struggle with the demands of regular maintenance and emergency repairs, particularly if they lack experience in handling or coordinating these issues efficiently. 

This can lead to higher costs in the long term and dissatisfaction among tenants, which could increase turnover.

Time Management Challenges

Managing a property can be time-consuming, often requiring availability during irregular hours for emergencies and tenant communications. 

For landlords with other responsibilities, such as a full-time job or family commitments, juggling these demands can be stressful and might lead to burnout or neglect of the property.

Cash Flow Management

Effective property management requires adept financial oversight, including the management of rental income, operating expenses, and savings for future repairs.

Mismanagement of these funds can lead to cash flow problems, potentially affecting the ability to maintain or improve the property and handle financial obligations like mortgage payments or property taxes.

Personal Stress and Emotional Involvement

Dealing directly with tenants can sometimes be emotionally challenging, especially in situations involving complaints, evictions, or conflicts. 

Emotional involvement can make it difficult to make impartial decisions and handle disputes professionally, which might lead to further issues or even legal complications.

Scaling Limitations

For landlords looking to expand their property portfolio, self-management can become increasingly impractical. 

The workload and complexity of managing multiple properties can limit growth potential and make it difficult to manage each property effectively.

Considerations for Self-Managing

While the benefits of hiring a property manager are advantageous to landlords, self-managing can be suitable for landlords who possess certain conditions:

  • Own just one rental property
  • Reside close to the property and have flexible schedules
  • Have extensive experience in real estate or property management
  • Enjoy hands-on involvement and direct interaction with tenants

Even in these situations, the demands of property management can be unpredictable and cut in significantly on personal time and resources.

Conclusion

Deciding between hiring a property manager and self-managing is a significant decision that impacts both the profitability and the sustainability of your rental property investment. 

For most landlords, the benefits of hiring a professional property manager—ranging from their expertise in legal compliance to efficient day-to-day property operations—provide reasons to opt for professional management. 

It allows landlords not only to free up their time but also to ensure their properties are professionally maintained, potentially increasing their profitability and the long-term value of their investments.

A property management company like Home Choice Property Management can assist you in handling your rental property, saving you time, money, and hassle. 

Call Home Choice Property Management today if you have inquiries.